NCAR logo

f09.B-0p5xCO2.cfmip.cf41.Y51-150
and
f09.B-PI.tn15.cmip6.j01.re.Y601-700

Set 9



TSA modified control Comparison
Model f09.B-0p5xCO2.cfmip.cf41.Y51-150 f09.B-PI.tn15.cmip6.j01.re.Y601-700 Summary
RMSE 3.88 2.38 +1.50
RMSE % Area 17.97 71.77 -53.80
ANN Bias -3.14 0.02 +3.12
ANN Bias % Area 21.91 76.54 -54.63
DJF Bias -4.47 -1.05 +3.42
DJF Bias % Area 13.14 85.10 -71.96
MAM Bias -2.98 0.12 +2.86
MAM Bias % Area 25.38 73.05 -47.67
JJA Bias -2.07 0.82 +1.25
JJA Bias % Area 34.39 64.14 -29.75
SON Bias -3.22 0.00 +3.22
SON Bias % Area 25.67 72.83 -47.16
% Area with r>0.9 85.01 83.37 +1.64


PREC modified control Comparison
Model f09.B-0p5xCO2.cfmip.cf41.Y51-150 f09.B-PI.tn15.cmip6.j01.re.Y601-700 Summary
RMSE 1.10 1.19 -0.09
RMSE % Area 5.67 1.94 +3.73
ANN Bias 0.19 0.32 -0.13
ANN Bias % Area 19.36 9.09 +10.27
DJF Bias 0.31 0.48 -0.17
DJF Bias % Area 18.13 7.93 +10.20
MAM Bias 0.28 0.38 -0.10
MAM Bias % Area 16.48 9.19 +7.29
JJA Bias -0.02 0.10 -0.08
JJA Bias % Area 17.81 13.72 +4.09
SON Bias 0.20 0.34 -0.14
SON Bias % Area 20.25 10.88 +9.37
% Area with r>0.9 48.82 46.87 +1.95


ASA modified control Comparison
Model f09.B-0p5xCO2.cfmip.cf41.Y51-150 f09.B-PI.tn15.cmip6.j01.re.Y601-700 Summary
RMSE 6.14 5.05 +1.09
RMSE % Area 9.24 27.88 -18.64
ANN Bias 1.66 0.16 +1.50
ANN Bias % Area 17.31 24.35 -7.04
DJF Bias 4.93 2.89 +2.04
DJF Bias % Area 12.64 27.92 -15.28
MAM Bias 2.86 1.19 +1.67
MAM Bias % Area 13.03 26.85 -13.82
JJA Bias 2.15 1.01 +1.14
JJA Bias % Area 8.71 19.28 -10.57
SON Bias 0.54 -1.07 -0.53
SON Bias % Area 20.86 16.26 +4.60
% Area with r>0.9 25.69 25.22 +0.47


LHEAT modified control Comparison
Model f09.B-0p5xCO2.cfmip.cf41.Y51-150 f09.B-PI.tn15.cmip6.j01.re.Y601-700 Summary
RMSE 18.02 19.65 -1.63
RMSE % Area 18.51 5.96 +12.55
ANN Bias 8.01 11.22 -3.21
ANN Bias % Area 19.90 6.17 +13.73
DJF Bias 9.84 12.41 -2.57
DJF Bias % Area 18.13 4.12 +14.01
MAM Bias 9.32 12.89 -3.57
MAM Bias % Area 27.05 7.56 +19.49
JJA Bias 5.13 9.52 -4.39
JJA Bias % Area 29.02 20.23 +8.79
SON Bias 7.53 9.81 -2.28
SON Bias % Area 15.23 5.15 +10.08
% Area with r>0.9 60.98 60.34 +0.64


GPP modified control Comparison
Model f09.B-0p5xCO2.cfmip.cf41.Y51-150 f09.B-PI.tn15.cmip6.j01.re.Y601-700 Summary
RMSE 1.32 1.43 -0.11
RMSE % Area 11.01 2.18 +8.83
ANN Bias -0.52 0.16 +0.36
ANN Bias % Area 16.69 8.10 +8.59
DJF Bias -0.18 0.37 -0.19
DJF Bias % Area 15.34 5.26 +10.08
MAM Bias -0.39 0.34 +0.05
MAM Bias % Area 21.29 7.54 +13.75
JJA Bias -1.13 -0.33 +0.80
JJA Bias % Area 16.47 15.54 +0.93
SON Bias -0.41 0.25 +0.16
SON Bias % Area 17.26 7.24 +10.02
% Area with r>0.9 46.66 45.04 +1.62

TLAI modified control Comparison
Model f09.B-0p5xCO2.cfmip.cf41.Y51-150 f09.B-PI.tn15.cmip6.j01.re.Y601-700 Summary
RMSE 0.90 1.09 -0.19
RMSE % Area 22.36 6.01 +16.35
ANN Bias 0.17 0.60 -0.43
ANN Bias % Area 33.03 18.20 +14.83
DJF Bias 0.22 0.61 -0.39
DJF Bias % Area 32.60 15.13 +17.47
MAM Bias 0.11 0.52 -0.41
MAM Bias % Area 30.15 18.13 +12.02
JJA Bias 0.06 0.53 -0.47
JJA Bias % Area 30.60 22.00 +8.60
SON Bias 0.27 0.72 -0.45
SON Bias % Area 35.30 15.95 +19.35
% Area with r>0.9 6.04 7.13 --1.09