NCAR logo

f09.B-2xCO2.cfmip.cf40.Y51-150
and
f09.B-PI.tn15.cmip6.j01.re.Y601-700

Set 9



TSA modified control Comparison
Model f09.B-2xCO2.cfmip.cf40.Y51-150 f09.B-PI.tn15.cmip6.j01.re.Y601-700 Summary
RMSE 4.68 2.38 +2.30
RMSE % Area 12.63 81.66 -69.03
ANN Bias 4.17 0.02 +4.15
ANN Bias % Area 14.05 84.64 -70.59
DJF Bias 3.52 -1.05 +2.47
DJF Bias % Area 28.77 69.92 -41.15
MAM Bias 4.01 0.12 +3.89
MAM Bias % Area 15.40 83.29 -67.89
JJA Bias 4.80 0.82 +3.98
JJA Bias % Area 11.05 87.64 -76.59
SON Bias 4.18 0.00 +4.18
SON Bias % Area 14.93 83.77 -68.84
% Area with r>0.9 82.48 83.37 --0.89


PREC modified control Comparison
Model f09.B-2xCO2.cfmip.cf40.Y51-150 f09.B-PI.tn15.cmip6.j01.re.Y601-700 Summary
RMSE 1.40 1.19 +0.21
RMSE % Area 1.68 11.88 -10.20
ANN Bias 0.45 0.32 +0.13
ANN Bias % Area 6.80 26.39 -19.59
DJF Bias 0.63 0.48 +0.15
DJF Bias % Area 8.21 29.48 -21.27
MAM Bias 0.53 0.38 +0.15
MAM Bias % Area 8.94 25.09 -16.15
JJA Bias 0.16 0.10 +0.06
JJA Bias % Area 7.67 24.11 -16.44
SON Bias 0.46 0.34 +0.12
SON Bias % Area 4.98 32.32 -27.34
% Area with r>0.9 37.88 46.87 --8.99


ASA modified control Comparison
Model f09.B-2xCO2.cfmip.cf40.Y51-150 f09.B-PI.tn15.cmip6.j01.re.Y601-700 Summary
RMSE 5.07 5.05 +0.02
RMSE % Area 16.50 19.41 -2.91
ANN Bias -1.15 0.16 +0.99
ANN Bias % Area 13.55 24.68 -11.13
DJF Bias 0.59 2.89 -2.30
DJF Bias % Area 18.53 21.31 -2.78
MAM Bias -0.47 1.19 -0.72
MAM Bias % Area 17.57 20.30 -2.73
JJA Bias 0.34 1.01 -0.67
JJA Bias % Area 11.26 3.27 +7.99
SON Bias -2.20 -1.07 +1.13
SON Bias % Area 5.23 26.18 -20.95
% Area with r>0.9 18.14 25.22 --7.08


LHEAT modified control Comparison
Model f09.B-2xCO2.cfmip.cf40.Y51-150 f09.B-PI.tn15.cmip6.j01.re.Y601-700 Summary
RMSE 20.62 19.65 +0.97
RMSE % Area 3.42 10.50 -7.08
ANN Bias 11.91 11.22 +0.69
ANN Bias % Area 5.73 9.47 -3.74
DJF Bias 13.26 12.41 +0.85
DJF Bias % Area 6.29 11.99 -5.70
MAM Bias 14.11 12.89 +1.22
MAM Bias % Area 8.38 20.56 -12.18
JJA Bias 10.72 9.52 +1.20
JJA Bias % Area 14.52 19.76 -5.24
SON Bias 9.26 9.81 -0.55
SON Bias % Area 7.23 13.07 -5.84
% Area with r>0.9 57.15 60.34 --3.19


GPP modified control Comparison
Model f09.B-2xCO2.cfmip.cf40.Y51-150 f09.B-PI.tn15.cmip6.j01.re.Y601-700 Summary
RMSE 1.80 1.43 +0.37
RMSE % Area 0.08 20.22 -20.14
ANN Bias 0.73 0.16 +0.57
ANN Bias % Area 1.65 22.33 -20.68
DJF Bias 0.85 0.37 +0.48
DJF Bias % Area 2.10 17.23 -15.13
MAM Bias 0.98 0.34 +0.64
MAM Bias % Area 2.04 26.13 -24.09
JJA Bias 0.36 -0.33 +0.03
JJA Bias % Area 6.96 23.27 -16.31
SON Bias 0.72 0.25 +0.47
SON Bias % Area 1.17 20.58 -19.41
% Area with r>0.9 38.71 45.04 --6.33

TLAI modified control Comparison
Model f09.B-2xCO2.cfmip.cf40.Y51-150 f09.B-PI.tn15.cmip6.j01.re.Y601-700 Summary
RMSE 1.31 1.09 +0.22
RMSE % Area 1.72 23.35 -21.63
ANN Bias 0.89 0.60 +0.29
ANN Bias % Area 10.05 35.17 -25.12
DJF Bias 0.90 0.61 +0.29
DJF Bias % Area 8.36 36.28 -27.92
MAM Bias 0.79 0.52 +0.27
MAM Bias % Area 10.91 33.23 -22.32
JJA Bias 0.84 0.53 +0.31
JJA Bias % Area 12.67 32.38 -19.71
SON Bias 1.00 0.72 +0.28
SON Bias % Area 8.02 34.80 -26.78
% Area with r>0.9 6.13 7.13 --1.00